Angi can be worth it for a contractor, but only if you count what a signed job costs, not a lead. Angi publishes no price list: fees follow the task, location and demand, each request goes to up to five pros, and you pay whether or not you open it. Thumbtack lets you set the price. Your own website charges no fee per lead. For a general contractor bidding five-figure remodels, that decides it.
Why a remodel lead is priced by the job
Both marketplaces tie what you pay to what the job is worth. Thumbtack’s help center says its “goal is to make the cost match how valuable the job is,” and that prices vary with “the type and size of the job, how many pros are available, and your market.” The Angi Leads pro FAQ, on what used to be HomeAdvisor’s pro center, puts it more plainly: “Different sized jobs have different Lead Fees.”
That matters more in general contracting than in most trades, because the jobs are big. The 2025 Cost vs Value report puts the national average cost of a midrange minor kitchen remodel at $28,458, a midrange bath remodel at $26,138, and a midrange major kitchen remodel at $82,793. A lead for work that size gets priced as one.
So “which is cheapest” can’t be settled from a rate card, since neither site prints one. It comes down to three things you can check yourself:
- what you pay each time a homeowner reaches you,
- how many other contractors that homeowner is talking to,
- how many of those leads turn into a signed contract.
How much do contractors pay to be on Angi?
Angi, the company once called Angie’s List, doesn’t publish a dollar figure. Its help center says “lead fees change based on task, homeowner location, and demand for the work,” and that each project request is matched “with no more than five pros.” The terms that decide your real cost, all from Angi’s own help pages read on November 15, 2026:
- When you’re charged: “as soon as both you and the homeowner show interest in connecting with each other.”
- Opened or not: “You are charged for leads whether or not you open or respond to them.”
- Credits: “In some cases, you can request a lead credit” for a lead that isn’t relevant to your work.
- Budgets: on a subscription, “your monthly budget is set annually per your contract.” Without one you’re billed weekly, and Angi’s billing FAQ says the last lead of the month can take you past the budget. Its own example is a $500 budget that ends the month at $520.
- Opportunities: jobs you pick from the Opportunities tab are billed “in addition to your monthly budget.”
You pay for the lead you never opened. Angi charges once both sides show interest, whether or not you open or answer the lead. On a week when you’re on a job site all day, that’s money spent on homeowners who may already be hearing from four other contractors.
How Thumbtack sets the price you pay
Thumbtack works the other way round: you pick the price. Its help center says it uses “exact lead prices,” set with a slider for each service, and “the price you set for a lead is the exact amount you’ll pay.” When a homeowner contacts you from search and the job matches your preferences, you auto-pay.
Four Thumbtack terms to read before you set that slider:
- The price is also a bid. A higher lead price “makes you more competitive for those leads.” Your profile, your rating and reviews, and how quickly you respond also decide how many leads you get.
- The weekly budget can run over. If the last lead costs more than what’s left, you pay the full price. The overrun is capped at 40% of your budget or $40 plus 2% of it, whichever is less.
- Minimums can move. Thumbtack “may occasionally adjust the minimum prices,” and a price at or near the minimum can rise with it.
- Opportunities and preset jobs bill differently. Quoting an Opportunity is free; you pay the price shown only if the homeowner replies. A preset job has no upfront cost, and Thumbtack keeps a percentage of the job price instead.
Is Thumbtack free for contractors?
Not for leads. Every lead from a homeowner who contacts you is charged at your lead price. Only preset jobs skip the upfront charge, and they cost you a share of the job instead. On a $26,000 bath, a percentage of the job price is a very different fee from the same percentage on a small repair.
What the HomeAdvisor case says to ask any lead seller
In January 2023 the FTC ordered HomeAdvisor to pay up to $7.2 million in redress, money the FTC said would compensate home service providers, and it approved the final consent order, a settlement, in April 2023. The FTC alleged that HomeAdvisor told service providers they would “only… receive leads matching the types of services they provide and their preferred geographic area,” when many did not, and that it claimed its leads became jobs “at rates much higher than it can substantiate.” At the time, providers paid an annual membership of $287.99 plus a separate fee for each lead.
The order bars HomeAdvisor from misrepresenting its leads, including whether they come from people “ready to hire a service provider” or who “submitted a request for home services directly to HomeAdvisor.” Those are the questions to put to any lead seller before you sign:
- Did the homeowner ask for help on your own site, or on a partner’s?
- How many contractors get the same request?
- What counts as a bad lead, and what do I get back for it?
- What’s the cancellation term, and is any add-on “free” only for the first month?
Write down the seller’s answers. Note the date and the rep’s name. If the leads don’t match what you were told, that note is what you bring to a credit request.
Multiple bids make a shared lead a bidding round
Remodels are bought by comparing bids, and homeowners are told to do it. The FTC’s advice on avoiding home improvement scams says to “get multiple estimates” and not to automatically choose the lowest bidder. A homeowner who sends one Angi request can be matched with up to five pros, and is still free to collect more estimates after that.
Our read: when a contract runs into five figures and the homeowner is gathering bids anyway, a shared lead starts you in a field of up to five, and you pay to enter it. A homeowner who fills in the form on your own project page found you in the results and wrote to you. They may still get other bids, but you aren’t one of five names a platform sent them.
That changes what wins the job:
- Speed on a marketplace lead, where Thumbtack counts response time in how many leads you get.
- Proof on your own site: the finished kitchen in their town, the scope, the license number.
What a visit to your own pages costs
A homeowner who finds your kitchen remodel page in Google’s organic results and sends a request costs nothing per click and nothing per lead. The cost sits elsewhere: the site, the pages, and the months it takes them to rank.
For a sense of what that visit would cost to buy, LocalBiz’s analysis of DataForSEO data (November 2026) puts advertisers’ average estimated cost per click on general contracting searches at $14.02. The dearest is “basement finishing” at $23.13. Across the 25 cities we checked, the contracting search with the city name runs from $4.40 a click in El Paso to $68.33 in Chicago. Those are click prices, before anyone sends a request.
The searches are there to rank for. From the same data:
| Search | US searches a month | Advertisers’ cost per click |
|---|---|---|
| general contractor near me | 135,000 | $10.70 |
| kitchen remodel | 74,000 | $15.78 |
| bathroom remodel cost | 33,100 | $20.51 |
| remodeling contractor | 22,200 | $14.44 |
| basement finishing | 12,100 | $23.13 |
“Remodeling contractor” peaked at 90,500 searches in September 2026, against 9,900 in May. A page meant to catch that fall rush needs to be live well before September. Our post on general contractor keywords goes through which project searches deserve a page of their own.
The license check happens before the call
A remodel customer checks you out before they call. The FTC tells homeowners to “check with your state or county government to confirm a contractor’s license” and to “read reviews with a critical eye,” and says the contract should carry your license number. Some states also require the number in your ads; California’s rule is in our post on the CSLB license number in ads and on your site.
On a marketplace, your profile sits on the platform’s page, next to the other pros it shows. On your own site, every project page can carry your license number, the towns you build in, photos of finished work and what each job involved. That’s the page a homeowner lands on after searching “kitchen remodel” and their town, and it answers the checks before they make them.
Is it worth advertising on Angi? Count cost per signed job
Lead price alone won’t tell you which channel is cheapest. Count every channel the same way for three months:
| Channel | What you pay for | Who else gets the homeowner | Your number |
|---|---|---|---|
| Angi | Each lead, fee set by task, location and demand | Up to five pros per request | Spend ÷ signed jobs |
| Thumbtack | Each lead, at the price you set per service | Leads chose you; Opportunities already contacted others | Spend ÷ signed jobs |
| Your website | The site and its pages, no fee per lead | Nobody is sent the request | Site cost ÷ signed jobs |
Write the source on every estimate you send and every contract you sign. A channel that costs more per lead can still win if it signs more kitchens, and one that looks cheap per lead can lose if those homeowners only wanted a number to compare.
Every LocalBiz site has a quote form on every page, and each request is emailed to you and saved in your dashboard. There’s no fee per request, and no other contractor is sent it. LocalBiz doesn’t track phone calls, so ask callers how they found you and log it next to the form requests.
For where marketplaces fit next to referrals, your Google profile and your site, see our contractor marketing guide. What LocalBiz builds for remodelers, a page for each service in each town you build in, is on the general contractors page, with plans on the pricing page.
Frequently asked questions
Is Angi worth it for general contractors?
It can be, if the jobs it brings cost less to win than jobs from your other channels. Angi publishes no price list: lead fees follow the task, location and demand, each request is matched with up to five pros, and you’re charged whether or not you open the lead. Track what you spend on Angi against the contracts you sign from it for a few months, then compare that with your own website and referrals.
How much does a Thumbtack lead cost a contractor?
Thumbtack doesn’t publish one price. You set an exact lead price for each service with a slider, and that is what you pay when a matching homeowner contacts you. Thumbtack says it aims to match the cost to the job’s value, so a large remodel lead is priced higher, and a higher price also makes you more competitive for those leads. Its minimum prices can change.
What did the FTC order HomeAdvisor to pay over its leads?
In January 2023 the FTC ordered HomeAdvisor to pay up to $7.2 million in redress, to compensate the service providers, and approved the final consent order in April 2023. The FTC alleged the company told service providers their leads would match their services and area when many did not, and claimed lead-to-job rates it couldn’t back up. The order bars it from misrepresenting its leads.
Are leads from my own contractor website free?
There is no fee per lead when a homeowner finds your page in Google’s organic results and sends a request. The cost is the site, the project and town pages, and the months they take to rank. For comparison, advertisers paid an estimated $14.02 a click on general contracting searches in LocalBiz’s November 2026 analysis of DataForSEO data, and $23.13 for basement finishing.
Sources
- LocalBiz analysis of DataForSEO data, November 2026 (general contracting search volumes and advertisers' estimated cost per click, US)
- Angi Help Center — Opportunities and Leads, Frequently Asked Questions (dated October 15, 2026)
- Angi Help Center — Billing, Frequently Asked Questions (dated March 5, 2026)
- Angi Help Center — How A Monthly Budget Works (dated August 14, 2026)
- Angi Leads — Pro FAQs (read November 15, 2026)
- Thumbtack Help — How much do I pay for leads and opportunities? (read November 15, 2026)
- Thumbtack Help — How to set my lead prices (read November 15, 2026)
- Thumbtack Help — What are leads, preset jobs, and opportunities? (read November 15, 2026)
- FTC — FTC Order Requires HomeAdvisor to Pay $7.2 Million and Stop Deceptively Marketing its Leads (January 23, 2023)
- FTC — FTC Approves Final Order against HomeAdvisor, Inc. (April 21, 2023)
- FTC Consumer Advice — How To Avoid a Home Improvement Scam (July 2022)
- JLC — 2025 Cost vs Value Report, national averages